Let’s complain about the Internet… using the Internet
This is one of my favorite things in the world: people complaining about the Internet via the Internet. I love it when Facebook users post angry status updates every time Facebook makes another privacy-invading change or UI disaster. They complain and yet they adapt to the changes because, if they want their voices to be heard, they must remain on the network that allows them to be heard.
In this debate, Mr. Keen is this exact kind of person. complaining about the thing that he hates, while using that exact thing. It’s like complaining about how much you hate peanut butter as you slather another layer onto your bread.
I view this debate from a more philosophical point of view as opposed to technical. Humans created a technology that has both advanced and hindered society. Mr. Keen feels as if this technology is more of a hindrance than a boon. Yet, Mr. Keen runs a blog with hundreds of readers, taking advantage of this very technology. He claims that the Internet is best used for activities such as research and the sending of information. What he does not say is that his blog is not contributing to these tasks at all. His place in the blogosphere is a waste of space, a waste of the infinite Internet.
This debate of technology is a great example of the flaws of humanity. We are able to have excellent debates, gain followers, make enemies, all while we contradict ourselves. We are intentionally unintentionally (yes, I said that) hypocritical but somehow the validity of our arguments still stand.
Additionally, we also learn a lot about narrowmindedness – which I am not using in a negative light. Mr. Keen claims that the Web is used solely for the distribution and consumption of pop culture, consumerist things. However, he comes to this conclusion by searching the Top 6 blogs. Of course the top anything blogs will be associated with pop culture because, well, that’s what makes it popular. It is unlikely that anyone could kind valuable information on the Internet without doing a fair amount of careful research. It was once a popular idea that the Earth was flat, this does not make it right.
So, yes, I agree that the Internet is littered with virtual garbage, but that does not mean, with careful digging and a good cleanup crew, treasure cannot be found.